When the Atom processor, just doesn’t cut it.

I currently have a Dell Mini 9 netbook which has an Intel Atom N270 processor running at 1.6Ghz on a 533Mhz FSB.  Since the “netbook” is supposed to be a mini laptop, you’d expect the processor to handle what you’re trying to do, right?  Not exactly.  We live in an age of Flash video, 720p/1080p everything, really complex websites and everything being in the “cloud”.  Since netbooks are meant to be internet only laptops, they incredibly fail at this point and I’ll tell you why.
I don’t know who came up with “netbooks”, or who came up with the initial specs of them, but let me tell you, they suck ass.  I know they’re meant to be inexpensive counterparts to regular (read: expensive) laptops, but when the hardware on these guys fails to do what they’re supposed to do, you’d think these comapnies would take a step back and try to fix it.  There’s a few inherent flaws in the design of netbooks, the first being the screen size/resolution.  My Mini 9 has a 9″ screen (thus the 9…clever I know) but a resolution of only 1024×600.  That’s not even the resolution of the iPad or anything else for that matter.  1024×600 is such a low resolution, you can’t do very much, and you’re stuck with incessant scrolling on web pages.  Second, is the video card/chipset.  The Mini 9 (and countless other netbooks) utilize the Intel 950 chipset, which gives you the GMA950 graphics chip and the 945E (for Express!) chipset.  What’s horrible about the GMA950 is that this is the basic of basic for graphics chips, and barely has enough power to give you Aero Glass.  Since the GMA doesn’t offer any sort of acceleration, don’t even think about using Flash 10.1.  The 945E chipset unfortunately only support 2GB of RAM and will refuse to POST with anything larger.  Why would you need more than 2GB of RAM?  Because you can never have enough RAM.  Now I understand that there are some netbooks out there that have the ION chipset from nVidia or even the ION2, but it’s still paired with the Atom processor (which I’ll get to in just a quick minute).  Third, since the netbook is small, so is the keyboard and space to rest your hands while typing.  The keys are so tiny on these these, I feel like I could type faster using my cell phone.  I also don’t have all the keys that I’d normally have on a keyboard, even with the Fn key.  And finally, the Intel Atom processor!  Most netbooks use the Intel Atom N270 CPU, which is only a single core processor with “HyperThreading” (read: a crap attempt to make you think you have a dual core CPU).  Some netbooks out there, do have dual core Atoms, but these are significantly more expensive.  Since the processor only runs at 1.6Ghz, it’s definitely not the fastest thing out there, hell the Nexus One is close to that speed alone!

Let’s give you some examples as to how the Atom processor simply fails (and netbooks in general).  As I mentioned earlier, people love watching YouTube/Hulu/Vimeo/etc…which uses Flash.  As most of you know, Flash is an incredible resource hog and since it’s a bloated piece of software, it runs everything in software mode (read: uses CPU).  Just running a basic 360p video from YouTube causes the CPU to jump to 50-60% if not more.  Why?  Why should I have such a high CPU usage just for watching a simple 360p video?  That’s not even counting the CPU usage from the OS itself, any programs you have open, etc…So just watching that video, could tax your CPU to 100%.  Great, stuttery video.  Don’t even think about watching a 720p video on YouTube, it just won’t play properly.  This is just video alone!  Imagine trying to play Farmville, or CafeWorld on Facebook, you’re going to get 100% CPU no doubt.  So while you were able to play these games on your desktop or even your latop, you’re shit out of luck on a netbook, mostly because of the shit CPU inside.  There are HD accelerators available for netbooks, one being the Broadcom Crystal HD miniPCI-e card.  However, inside the Mini9, there’s only one miniPCI-e slot, so you have to lose WiFi (ugh…).  This card only allows acceleration of Flash for video (not the card’s fault, pure on Adobe), so if you wanted to play those Flash games, good luck, this card won’t help.  This card WILL help if you wanted to watch 720p HD mkv videos, but beware of Windows sucking up CPU usage randomly, causing your HD video to stutter like crazy.  So there’s another thing that your netbook can’t do.

So is there really anything a netbook is good for?  Not really.  Unless you only view google.com or sites that aren’t graphically intensive, or doesn’t use any Flash, you’re going to have a horrible experience.  I love how small the netbook is, I love how convenient it is, but each time I use it, it makes me cry as to how lacking it is.  Why do I have a netbook instead of a desktop/laptop?  I had to consolidate (read: needed money) things and sold my laptop, so I’m stuck with the netbook for now.  I need power, and this thing just doesn’t cut it at all.

5 Comments

  1. Dave says:

    Very useful post, thank you!

  2. markus wallett says:

    There’s no doubt that when it comes to crap processors, there’s no better than Intel’s ATOM.

  3. George Greek says:

    I agree with you on all counts. You would think that in this day and age of HD video and ubiquitous ‘flash’ sites, Intel engineers would have released an Atom/video combination that could easily handle at least 720p video while suring the web. Perhaps the newest dual core Atom’s, like the D510 and D525, with better video, could handle these demands better than the N270 era chips? If you look at CPU benchmark ratings, the N270 comes in at about 304 (about the same as a P4, 2.4 GHz chip), and the twin core D525 a much more respectable 727.

  4. MAS says:

    Intel has just fucked you with Atom as they fucked entire world Intel Atom is a big SHIT Intel should face the pridon for this crap FUCK INTEL FUCK ATOM
    sell it and buy Amd Zacate laptop and enjoy full hd on you tube and others at full speed.

  5. Mr Mark says:

    I agree, as an owner of a Samsung NC10, the Atom processor is absolute crap. It is SOOOOO irritating to use, every time i even just want to do something simple, like scroll down a web page, there’s a delay between me moving the mouse wheel, or clicking on the scroll bar, and it actually responding. Every time.

    I thought these netbooks were great at first, but I soon realised, they are not worth it.

    My 17inch laptop is still as portable as i need it to be. I appriciate people will still need something more portable than that – but you DON’T need a netbook, trust me.

    If you need something very portable, just buy the smallest laptop you can, with at LEAST a dual core processor. That is absolute MINIMUM.

    To buy something with an atom core/single core, as I have found out to my dismay, is simply stupid and pointless, and very very frustrating.

    Seriously they people that designed netbooks, and decided atom processors were good enough for us, should be lined up an shot.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign in with Twitter

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>